Key West, the southernmost point of the continental United States, is known for its turquoise waters, coral reefs, and vibrant nightlife. But what many people don’t realize is that Key West is also home to a thriving food scene, with everything from fresh seafood to Cuban cuisine to fine dining. Whether you’re looking for a casual bite or a special occasion meal, you’re sure to find something to your liking in Key West.
One of the best things about Key West’s food scene is the variety of options. You’ll find everything from casual seafood shacks to fine dining restaurants, and everything in between. If you’re looking for a casual meal, there are plenty of places to get fresh seafood, Cuban sandwiches, and other local favorites. For a more special occasion, there are several restaurants that offer fine dining menus with dishes like lobster, steak, and seafood. No matter what you’re looking for, you’re sure to find something to your liking in Key West.
Another great thing about Key West’s food scene is the use of fresh, local ingredients. Many restaurants in Key West source their ingredients from local farms and fishermen, which means that you’re getting the freshest possible food. This is especially true for seafood, which is a staple of the Key West diet. Whether you’re eating at a casual seafood shack or a fine dining restaurant, you can be sure that the seafood you’re eating is fresh and delicious. In addition to fresh seafood, Key West’s restaurants also use a variety of other local ingredients, such as fruits, vegetables, and herbs. This gives the food a unique flavor that you won’t find anywhere else.
The Flavors of Duval Street
Conch Republic Seafood Company
Start your culinary journey on Duval Street at Conch Republic Seafood Company, a renowned institution known for its fresh seafood and vibrant atmosphere. Take a seat at the outdoor patio or indoor dining room and indulge in their signature dish, the Key West Pink Shrimp. These succulent shrimp are lightly seasoned and grilled to perfection, showcasing the natural sweetness of the local catch. Other must-tries include the Florida Lobster Roll, piled high with tender lobster meat, and the Conch Fritters, a crispy and flavorful appetizer that embodies the spirit of Key West.
Conch Republic Seafood Company also boasts an extensive drink menu, featuring tropical cocktails, local craft beers, and a wide selection of wines. Sip on a refreshing Mojito while enjoying the live music that often fills the air. Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast or simply seeking a lively dining experience, Conch Republic Seafood Company is a must-visit destination on Duval Street.
Other Culinary Delights on Duval Street
Beyond Conch Republic Seafood Company, Duval Street offers a diverse culinary landscape.
Dine at Five Guys Burgers & Fries for classic burgers, hot dogs, and crispy fries.
| Restaurant | Cuisine |
|---|---|
| Seven Fish Restaurant and Bar | Seafood, contemporary American |
| La Trattoria Oceanside Restaurant | Italian |
| Margaritaville Key West | American, Caribbean |
Sunset Dining Delights
Key West, Florida, is renowned for its picturesque sunsets and vibrant culinary scene. Watching the sun dip below the horizon while savoring a delectable meal is an unparalleled experience. Here are the top picks for sunset dining in Key West:
Best Waterfront Restaurants
### Latitudes Sunset Bar and Restaurant
Perched atop Sunset Pier, Latitudes Sunset Bar and Restaurant offers panoramic views of the sunset over Mallory Square. Indulge in fresh seafood, prime steaks, and innovative cocktails while soaking in the breathtaking ambiance. Reservations are highly recommended to secure a prime sunset-viewing table.
### Sunset Pier
Nestled on the lively waterfront, Sunset Pier boasts a casual atmosphere and waterfront dining at its finest. Savor Caribbean-inspired dishes, including fresh catches of the day, while enjoying live music and watching the sun cast its golden glow across the sky. The outdoor seating area provides an ideal setting for a memorable sunset dining experience.
Hidden Gems for the Discerning Palate
Venture beyond the tourist traps and discover culinary gems that will tantalize your taste buds. Here are some local favorites that offer an authentic slice of Key West’s gastronomic landscape:
1. The Stuffed Pig
This cozy spot in the heart of town is known for its generous portions and home-style comfort food. Their Cuban sandwiches are legendary, and the daily specials are always a treat.
2. Blue Heaven
Nestled among lush foliage, Blue Heaven is a Key West institution. Their breakfast is a must-try, featuring tropical fruit pancakes and fluffy omelets. Don’t miss their famous key lime pie.
3. The Café
This stylish café offers a sophisticated menu with international flair. Their tuna tartar is a standout, and their desserts are simply divine.
4. Hogfish Bar & Grill
Indulge in the freshest seafood while enjoying breathtaking waterfront views from this casual eatery. Their hogfish sandwich is a local delicacy, and their seafood platters will satisfy any craving.
Menu Highlights:
| Dish | Price |
| Hogfish Sandwich | $16 |
| Seafood Platter | $24 |
| Fresh Oysters | $12 |
Culinary Creations at the Conch Republic
Seafood Extravaganza at Conch Republic Seafood Company
Calling all seafood lovers! Conch Republic Seafood Company is a culinary haven for those who crave the freshest catches of the day. From succulent shrimp to tender scallops, their diverse menu showcases the bounty of the Atlantic Ocean. Indulge in their famous Key Largo Lobster Boil or savor the flavors of their Coastal Seafood Trio, which features grilled salmon, shrimp, and scallops.
Conch Delights at Louie’s Backyard
Experience the legendary Conch Republic in all its glory at Louie’s Backyard. This iconic establishment is renowned for its Conch Fritters, a crispy and flavorful appetizer that embodies the local culinary tradition. Their Conch Chowder is also a must-try, offering a rich and hearty taste of the sea.
Key Lime Extravaganza at Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe
Get ready to indulge in the irresistible embrace of Key Lime Pie at Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe. This beloved destination is a sanctuary for sweet tooths, offering a tantalizing array of key lime-infused treats. From creamy cheesecakes to decadent pies, there’s something for every key lime aficionado.
Tropical Fusion at Half Shell Raw Bar
Embark on a culinary adventure at Half Shell Raw Bar, where local flavors harmonize with tropical inspirations. Their Caribbean Seafood Jambalaya is a vibrant and aromatic dish that transports you to the heart of the islands, while their Smoked Fish Dip offers a tantalizing fusion of local seafood and smoky flavors.
Culinary Crossroads at Sunset Pier
Sunset Pier is a culinary destination that caters to diverse palates. Indulge in their signature Tuna Nachos, a delightful fusion of fresh tuna and nacho chips, or satisfy your seafood cravings with their Steamed Shellfish Platter, which features a generous selection of the ocean’s bounty. And don’t forget to savor the sunset views while enjoying your culinary delights.
| Signature Dish | Restaurant |
|---|---|
| Conch Fritters | Louie’s Backyard |
| Key Lime Pie | Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe |
| Caribbean Seafood Jambalaya | Half Shell Raw Bar |
| Tuna Nachos | Sunset Pier |
Waterfront Wonders for Foodies
Latitudes Sunset Key
Indulge in an exquisite fine dining experience at Latitudes Sunset Key, where panoramic waterfront views create an enchanting ambiance. Savor culinary masterpieces crafted by award-winning Chef Will Meyers, featuring innovative seafood dishes and locally sourced ingredients.
Louie’s Backyard
Escape to a tropical oasis at Louie’s Backyard. This beloved waterfront restaurant offers a laid-back atmosphere and tantalizing seafood classics. From grilled lobster to fresh catch of the day, every dish is a testament to the island’s culinary heritage.
Schooner Wharf Bar
Immerse yourself in the vibrant energy of Schooner Wharf Bar, a buzzing waterfront hub where locals and visitors alike gather. Watch the sunset while sipping on handcrafted cocktails and munching on delectable bar bites.
The Conch Republic Seafood Company
Feast on fresh seafood and succulent steaks at The Conch Republic Seafood Company. This family-friendly establishment boasts a charming waterfront deck, where you can enjoy panoramic harbor views while indulging in culinary delights.
Hogfish Bar & Grill
Embark on a casual dining experience at Hogfish Bar & Grill. Their namesake hogfish sandwich is a local favorite, along with an array of seafood, burgers, and salads. Enjoy your meal in their lively waterfront setting.
Sunset Pier Waterfront Bar
Escape to tranquility at Sunset Pier Waterfront Bar. This hidden gem offers stunning sunset views from their waterfront deck. Sip on refreshing cocktails, indulge in delicious appetizers, and soak up the magical atmosphere.
| Restaurant | Cuisine | Ambiance |
|---|---|---|
| Latitudes Sunset Key | Fine dining | Elegant, upscale |
| Louie’s Backyard | Seafood | Casual, relaxed |
| Schooner Wharf Bar | Bar bites | Lively, vibrant |
| The Conch Republic Seafood Company | Seafood, steaks | Family-friendly, panoramic views |
| Hogfish Bar & Grill | Seafood, burgers | Casual, lively |
| Sunset Pier Waterfront Bar | Appetizers, cocktails | Tranquil, romantic |
Late-Night Indulgences in Key West
After a day of exploring the vibrant streets of Key West, satisfy your late-night cravings with these delectable options.
24-Hour Indulgences
Quench your late-night thirst with Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop‘s renowned Key lime pie or cool off with a frosty margarita at Sloppy Joe’s Bar, a legendary haunt known for its lively atmosphere.
Late-Night Dining
Indulge in hearty dishes at The Conch Republic Seafood Company, which offers a delectable seafood menu until 11 PM. Alternatively, satisfy your sweet tooth with gourmet donuts at Glazed Donuts, open until midnight.
Street Food Delights
Savor the authentic flavors of Cuban street food at El Siboney Restaurant, a family-run establishment serving tasty sandwiches and empanadas. Don’t miss the mouthwatering Cuban coffee at Cuban Coffee Queen, a local favorite.
Late-Night Pizza Fix
Craving a late-night pizza fix? Head to Pizza Hut for a satisfying slice or order a whole pie from Papa John’s Pizza, both open until 1 AM.
Nightly Sweet Treats
Indulge in delectable desserts at Aunt Molly’s Confectionery, a charming candy shop with a wide selection of sweet temptations. Sample the rich chocolates at Key West Chocolate & Coffee Co., open until 10 PM.
Late-Night Cocktails
Sip on craft cocktails and enjoy live music at The Rum Bar, a vibrant establishment with a lively atmosphere. Alternatively, relax with a glass of wine at The Wine Garden, which boasts an extensive wine list.
Off-the-Beaten-Path Dining Adventures
Venture beyond the tourist hotspots of Key West to discover hidden culinary gems that offer unique and memorable dining experiences.
Dante’s Pool Bar
Indulge in waterfront dining at this secluded poolside bar, featuring exquisite seafood and tropical cocktails against a backdrop of stunning sunset views.
Fisherman’s Cafe
Step into a local haunt loved by fishermen and locals alike. Enjoy fresh catches of the day, including stone crab, snapper, and yellowtail, in a casual and authentic atmosphere.
915 Duval Street
Escape the crowds and immerse yourself in the vibrant local scene at this cozy bistro. Savory tapas, craft cocktails, and live music create an intimate and unforgettable evening.
Island Dogs
Embrace the laid-back island vibe at this hot dog and burger joint. Indulge in creative and flavorful toppings that elevate the classic American fare to a new level.
Blue Heaven
Nestled amidst lush gardens, this charming breakfast and lunch spot offers a serene escape. Enjoy farm-to-table dishes made with fresh ingredients, accompanied by signature Key Lime Pie.
Schooner Wharf Bar
Join the locals at this waterfront bar and grill. Feast on delectable seafood, including fresh oysters, shrimp, and grilled fish, while soaking up the breathtaking marina views.
Hot Tin Roof
Ascend to the rooftop of the Marquesa Hotel for a sophisticated dining experience overlooking the historic Mallory Square. Savor contemporary American cuisine with a focus on local flavors.
Eaton Street Seafood Market and Raw Bar
Immerse yourself in the vibrant seafood market atmosphere. Select your own oysters, clams, and shrimp, then have them freshly prepared for a unique and interactive dining experience.
Hogfish Bar & Grill
Satisfy your seafood cravings at this casual and colorful establishment. Enjoy daily catches, including their signature Hogfish tacos, accompanied by live music and a lively atmosphere.
A Culinary Journey through Key West’s History
Key West’s culinary scene is a reflection of its rich history and diverse influences. From conch fritters to Key lime pie, the island offers a tantalizing array of flavors that will delight any palate.
Hemingway’s Lunchroom
This historic eatery has been serving up classic American fare since the 1930s. Ernest Hemingway was a frequent patron, and his favorite dish, the Sloppy Joe, is still a menu staple.
Blue Heaven
Located in an old bungalow, Blue Heaven is known for its tropical ambiance and delicious brunch menu. The Key West omelet is a must-try, featuring local seafood and fresh fruit.
El Siboney Restaurant
This Cuban restaurant has been serving authentic Cuban cuisine for over 50 years. The Ropa Vieja, a tender stewed beef dish, is an unforgettable culinary experience.
Hogfish Bar & Grill
As the name suggests, Hogfish Bar & Grill specializes in hogfish, a local delicacy. The pan-seared hogfish is a succulent and flavorful dish that showcases the freshness of local ingredients.
Louie’s Backyard
Perched on the water’s edge, Louie’s Backyard serves up upscale seafood and tropical cocktails. The daily fresh catch is always a winner, grilled to perfection and served with a variety of sides.
Mattheessen’s Restaurant
This fine-dining establishment offers a sophisticated menu featuring American cuisine with a tropical twist. The seafood is especially noteworthy, with the Key West snapper a particular highlight.
Nine One Five
Nine One Five is a stylish restaurant located in a former cigar factory. The menu is eclectic and includes dishes like the Key West Paella and the Lobster Risotto.
Origen Restaurant
This Cuban-inspired restaurant serves up modern takes on classic Cuban dishes. The Ceviche is a refreshing and flavorful starter, while the Arroz con Pollo is a hearty and satisfying main course.
Azucar Cuban Cuisine & Rum Bar
Azucar is a vibrant and lively restaurant that offers a wide selection of Cuban dishes and cocktails. The Rotisserie Pig is a signature dish, slow-roasted to perfection.
Truman Waterfront Restaurant & Bar
This upscale restaurant overlooks the historic Truman Waterfront and offers a stunning view while you dine. The menu features seafood, steak, and a variety of other dishes, all prepared with the finest ingredients.
| Restaurant | Cuisine | Ambiance | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hemingway’s Lunchroom | Classic American | Historic, casual | $ |
| Blue Heaven | Tropical American | Bungalow-style, family-friendly | $ |
| El Siboney Restaurant | Cuban | Authentic, lively | $ |
| Hogfish Bar & Grill | Seafood (Hogfish) | Laid-back, local | $$ |
| Louie’s Backyard | Upscale Seafood | Waterfront, romantic | $$$ |
| Mattheessen’s Restaurant | American (Tropical Twist) | Fine-dining, sophisticated | $$$$ |
| Nine One Five | Eclectic American | Stylish, industrial | $$ |
| Origen Restaurant | Cuban-Inspired | Modern, vibrant | $$ |
| Azucar Cuban Cuisine & Rum Bar | Cuban | Lively, festive | $$ |
| Truman Waterfront Restaurant & Bar | Seafood, Steak | Upscale, waterfront | $$$ |
Best Places to Eat in Key West
Discover the culinary gems that make Key West a foodie’s paradise. From fresh seafood to international cuisine, here are the top dining destinations that will tantalize your taste buds.
Conch Republic Seafood Company offers a vibrant atmosphere and a menu brimming with seafood delicacies. Indulge in their succulent conch fritters or savor a heaping platter of fresh oysters.
For a taste of Italy, visit Truman’s Little White House Café. Their grilled octopus and homemade pasta dishes are culinary masterpieces. Don’t miss their signature key lime pie for a sweet finale.
If you crave Cuban flavors, El Siboney Restaurant is a must-visit. Their traditional Cuban sandwiches and ropa vieja are packed with authentic flavors. Be sure to order some sweet plantains to complement your meal.
People Also Ask About Best Places to Eat in Key West
Is there a dress code for these restaurants?
Most restaurants in Key West have a casual dress code, but it’s advisable to dress appropriately for the ambiance. For upscale dining options, smart casual attire is recommended.
What are the best places to eat seafood in Key West?
Conch Republic Seafood Company and Hogfish Bar & Grill are renowned for their fresh seafood and delicious conch dishes.
Are there any vegetarian or vegan options available in Key West?
Yes, Key West offers several vegetarian- and vegan-friendly restaurants, such as Mary Ellen’s Bar & Grill and The Green Parrot Bar. They have a wide selection of plant-based dishes to cater to all dietary preferences.
