5 Best Ice Cream Shops in Fort Myers, FL

An image of multiple ice cream cones topped with various toppings

$title$

Behold, ice cream enthusiasts of Fort Myers, Florida! Prepare your taste buds for a delectable expedition as we embark on a quest to uncover the most extraordinary ice cream havens that this vibrant city has to offer. From artisanal scoops bursting with bold flavors to refreshing treats that transport you to a tropical paradise, Fort Myers is a culinary melting pot of frozen delights just waiting to be savored. So buckle up, fellow ice cream adventurers, for a sweet journey that will tantalize your senses and leave you craving more.

Nestled amidst the charming streets of downtown Fort Myers, Kilwins Chocolates and Ice Cream is a veritable ice cream paradise, where the aroma of freshly churned cones fills the air. Their handcrafted ice cream, made with the finest ingredients and a touch of coastal charm, will have you savoring every single lick. From classic flavors like Vanilla Bean and Butter Pecan to tantalizing concoctions infused with local fruits, Kilwins has an eclectic selection that caters to every palate. And let’s not forget their signature waffle cones, the perfect complement to your frozen treat, freshly baked and ready to elevate your ice cream experience to new heights.

Just a short stroll away, The Ice Cream Factory lives up to its name, presenting an extensive menu of ice cream wonders that will leave you spoilt for choice. Their creamy scoops, adorned with an array of delectable toppings, will ignite your taste buds with delight. Whether you prefer the timeless appeal of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough or the zesty tang of Key Lime Pie, The Ice Cream Factory has a flavor combination that will resonate with your soul. But the true magic lies in their specialty creations, such as the decadent Turtle Sundae, a masterpiece adorned with caramel, pecans, and whipped cream, or the refreshing Watermelon Sorbet, a tantalizing treat that captures the essence of summer. Every scoop is a testament to their passion for creating ice cream that transcends the ordinary, inviting you on a journey of pure indulgence.

Savory Scoops: The Art of Ice Cream Creation in Fort Myers

Fort Myers, nestled along the picturesque coast of Southwest Florida, has emerged as a culinary destination, boasting an impressive array of ice cream parlors that elevate the frozen treat to an art form. One such establishment, Savory Scoops, has captured the imagination of locals and tourists alike with its imaginative flavors and artisanal craftsmanship.

The Alchemy of Ice Cream Creation

Inside the cozy confines of Savory Scoops, a symphony of flavors takes place. The team of skilled ice cream artisans, led by renowned chef Jenilee Farr, meticulously crafts each batch, balancing sweetness, creaminess, and texture to achieve the perfect equilibrium.

Chef Farr’s culinary background shines through in her innovative flavor combinations. From the tangy “Key Lime Pie” to the savory “Roasted Beets & Goat Cheese,” Savory Scoops defies expectations by blending traditional ice cream flavors with unexpected ingredients. The result is a tantalizing array of scoops that cater to every palate, from the adventurous to the traditional.

The dedication to freshness extends beyond the flavors. Savory Scoops sources its ingredients locally whenever possible, ensuring that each scoop bursts with the vibrant flavors of Southwest Florida. Their milk and cream come from nearby dairies, guaranteeing a smooth and creamy texture that complements the innovative flavors.

Flavor	Description
Key Lime Pie	Tangy key lime curd swirled into creamy vanilla ice cream, capturing the essence of the Sunshine State.
Roasted Beets & Goat Cheese	Earthy roasted beets paired with crumbles of tangy goat cheese, creating a savory and sweet symphony.
Coconut Cream	Tropical paradise in a scoop, with sweet and creamy coconut milk blended into velvety ice cream.

Indulge in the Sweetest Delights: Top Ice Cream Parlors in Fort Myers

The Chocolate Bison: A Haven for Dessert Connoisseurs

Step into The Chocolate Bison and immerse yourself in a world of sweet indulgence. This charming parlor boasts an impressive menu of handcrafted ice cream, tantalizing your taste buds with an array of classic and innovative flavors. From the timeless vanilla bean to the decadent chocolate peanut butter cup, there’s a treat for every palate.

Nestled in the heart of Downtown Fort Myers, The Chocolate Bison prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients to create its delectable masterpieces. Their ice cream is made daily on-site, ensuring the peak of freshness and flavor. Indulge in scoops or indulge in a mouthwatering waffle cone, each one a testament to the craftsmanship of their talented team.

Unleash Your Sweet Tooth with a Symphony of Flavors

Signature Flavors	Indulgent Creations
Vanilla Bean Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Salted Caramel	Affogato with Espresso Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches Chocolate-Dipped Cones

The Chocolate Bison’s dedication to quality doesn’t stop at their ice cream. They offer a carefully curated selection of craft sodas, fine teas, and premium coffee to perfectly complement your frozen treat. Whether you’re craving a sweet escape or a delightful treat to share, The Chocolate Bison is the ultimate destination for ice cream lovers.

An Array of Flavors: Gulf Coast’s Ice Cream Delights

Fort Myers, Florida, is an ice cream lover’s paradise, boasting a diverse range of flavors that tantalize the taste buds. From classic concoctions to inventive innovations, there’s a scoop to satisfy every craving. Dive into the sweet symphony of flavors that have made Fort Myers a culinary oasis:

Tropical Temptations: A Taste of Paradise

Fort Myers’ proximity to the Gulf Coast imbues its ice cream creations with tropical flair. Delight in the sweet embrace of coconut-infused flavors, where creamy vanilla dances with the exotic notes of toasted coconut. Mango and papaya lend their vibrant hues and tropical essence to refreshingly fruity scoops, transporting you to a blissful island retreat.

Authentic Italian: Gelato’s Creamy Embrace

For a taste of Italy’s culinary legacy, indulge in the authentic gelato found in Fort Myers. Crafted with fresh milk and the finest ingredients, gelato is a velvety delight that melts in your mouth. Pistachio and hazelnut gelato evokes the flavors of Tuscany, while chocolate gelato is a decadent indulgence that rivals the finest Swiss chocolates.

Beyond the Ordinary: Creative Concoctions

Fort Myers’ ice cream artisans go beyond the traditional, pushing the boundaries of flavor with imaginative concoctions. Beer-infused ice cream blends the smoothness of ice cream with the crisp notes of craft beer, resulting in a tantalizing fusion of flavors. Lavender and Earl Grey tea-infused ice creams offer a delightful blend of floral and herbal aromas, providing a refreshing and elegant twist on dessert.

Flavor	Description
Coconut Cream Pie	A creamy blend of coconut ice cream with swirls of graham cracker and whipped cream.
Key Lime Pie	Tart and tangy key lime ice cream with a graham cracker crust and whipped cream.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup	Rich chocolate ice cream studded with peanut butter cups.

From Classic to Culinary: Exploring the Unique Ice Cream Offerings in Fort Myers

The Sweetest Spots for Scoops

Embark on an epicurean adventure as you savor the finest ice cream creations in Fort Myers. From nostalgic classics to daring culinary delights, the city’s ice cream parlors promise an unforgettable gustatory experience.

Classic Flavors with a Twist

Indulge in the timeless flavors of vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry at renowned establishments like The Big Blue Ice Cream Parlor. Their smooth, creamy textures are a testament to generations of cherished memories. Don’t miss the opportunity to pair your scoop with decadent toppings like hot fudge, whipped cream, or rainbow sprinkles.

Culinary Creations that Defy Expectations

Fort Myers has emerged as a culinary hub, and its ice cream offerings reflect this creative spirit. At Pop the Cork Winery, you’ll find a wine-infused ice cream in flavors like Cabernet Sauvignon and Chardonnay. For a taste of the tropics, head to City Bean Coffee Roasters, where they craft ice cream with coconut milk and pineapple chunks.

A World of Flavors at Your Fingertips

Embark on a global ice cream journey at Miromar Outlets. Ben & Jerry’s invites you to discover their beloved classics, while Baskin-Robbins boasts an impressive 31 flavors to choose from. If you’re in the mood for something exotic, head to Cold Stone Creamery for their green tea or mango sorbet.

Flavor	Establishment
Cabernet Sauvignon Ice Cream	Pop the Cork Winery
Coconut Milk Pineapple Ice Cream	City Bean Coffee Roasters
Green Tea Sorbet	Cold Stone Creamery
Mango Sorbet	Cold Stone Creamery

The Cold Truth: Ranking the Must-Try Ice Cream Spots in Fort Myers

#5: Peterbrooke Chocolatier of Naples

Peterbrooke Chocolatier, situated just a short drive from Fort Myers in Naples, transports you to a realm of pure indulgence with its exquisite ice cream creations. Each scoop is a symphony of flavors, crafted with the finest ingredients and an unparalleled attention to detail. From the classic Vanilla Bean to the tantalizing Chocolate Raspberry Swirl, every bite promises an unforgettable culinary adventure.

Beyond its delectable ice cream, Peterbrooke offers an array of handcrafted chocolates, pastries, and coffee concoctions. The elegant ambiance, adorned with rich mahogany accents and plush seating, provides the perfect setting to savor these sweet treats.

If you’re looking for an exceptional ice cream experience that borders on the extraordinary, Peterbrooke Chocolatier of Naples is an absolute must-visit.

A Trip to Remember: Unforgettable Ice Cream Experiences in Fort Myers

Immerse yourself in the delectable world of ice cream in Fort Myers, where each scoop promises a moment of pure indulgence. From classic flavors to innovative concoctions, the city’s ice cream scene is a symphony of sweet sensations.

The Best of the Best: Five Ice Cream Havens

1. Yabba Island Grill

A tropical paradise in the heart of Fort Myers, Yabba Island Grill whips up mouthwatering milkshakes and ice cream sundaes topped with their famous cheesecake bites. Indulge in flavors like “Banana Pudding Pie” and “Strawberry Shortcake” for a taste of island bliss.

2. The Ice Cream Bar

Customize your dream scoop at The Ice Cream Bar, where you can choose from a tantalizing array of flavors and toppings. From classic chocolate to exotic “Purple Cow,” there’s something for every sweet tooth. Don’t miss their signature “Kitchen Sink” sundae, a towering masterpiece of sugary goodness.

3. Culver’s

Step into a cozy 1950s-style diner at Culver’s and savor their award-winning frozen custard. Their signature “Concrete Mixers” blend your favorite flavors with mix-ins like Oreos and hot fudge, creating a velvety smooth treat.

4. Dairy Queen

Satisfy your cravings with the iconic treats of Dairy Queen. Dive into a hand-dipped Blizzard, a whirlwind of soft serve ice cream and toppings, or indulge in a classic sundae topped with whipped cream and nuts.

5. Barnhill’s

Escape to a nostalgic ice cream parlor at Barnhill’s, where the vintage atmosphere transports you back in time. Sip on a creamy milkshake or savor a heaping bowl of their homemade ice cream, made with the finest ingredients.

Unveiling the Hidden Gems

6. Local Favorites and Off-the-Beaten-Path Gems

Discover hidden gems beyond the well-known ice cream parlors. Venture into local favorites like Blue Coast Burrito for their decadent churro ice cream sandwiches or head to the Old Bridge Coffee Haus for their artisanal ice cream crafted with locally roasted coffee beans.

For a unique twist, try the banana pudding ice cream at City Tavern or the creamy coconut ice cream at Thai Taste. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurous foodie, Fort Myers’ ice cream scene is sure to delight.

Location:	599 5th Avenue South, Naples, FL 34102
Hours:	Monday – Saturday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Website:	peterbrookechocolatier.com

Ice Cream Parlor	Signature Treat
The Ice Cream Bar	Kitchen Sink Sundae
Culver’s	Concrete Mixers
Dairy Queen	Hand-Dipped Blizzards

The Cream of the Crop: Fort Myers’ Award-Winning Ice Creameries

Subsection 7: Indulge in the Sweetest Treats

Fort Myers boasts a plethora of exceptional ice cream parlors that will tantalize your taste buds with their delectable creations. Here are seven of the most celebrated:

Indulge in the classic yet extraordinary flavors at **Ben & Jerry’s**, renowned for its chunky ice cream and euphoric atmosphere.

Discover the artisanal masterpieces of **The Ice Cream Factory**, where they churn their ice cream fresh daily, offering a rotating menu that will keep you coming back for more.

Transport yourself to a tropical paradise with **Paradise Ice Cream**, known for its vibrant flavors inspired by the islands, such as “Key Lime Pie” and “Coconut Cream”.

Explore the whimsical world of **Scoops ‘N Smiles**, where you can customize your sundae with a myriad of toppings and create your own unique dessert experience.

Embark on a sweet adventure at **Sweet Surrender Ice Cream Shop**, where they specialize in unique and captivating flavors like “Lavender Honey” and “Salted Caramel Pretzel”.

Immerse yourself in the nostalgia of **Walker’s Ice Cream**, a family-friendly spot that has been serving up scoops of joy since 1979.

Escape the ordinary and embrace the extraordinary at **Wicked Cream**, where they push the boundaries of flavor, offering unexpected and tantalizing combinations that will leave you craving more.

Parlor	Signature Flavor
Ben & Jerry’s	Chocolate Fudge Brownie
The Ice Cream Factory	Butter Pecan with Cream Cheese
Paradise Ice Cream	Key Lime Pie

Local Legends: Meet the Ice Cream Masters of Fort Myers

The Crave Ice Creamery

Nestled in the heart of downtown Fort Myers, The Crave Ice Creamery is a local icon known for its creative flavor concoctions. With a rotating menu that boasts over 40 flavors, from classics like vanilla bean to whimsical creations like bacon maple or key lime pie, The Crave offers something to satisfy every taste bud. Don’t miss their signature “Crave Cone,” a waffle cone dipped in chocolate and topped with your choice of toppings.

Pip’s Country Kitchen Ice Cream

Just a short drive from Fort Myers Beach, Pip’s Country Kitchen Ice Cream has been a beloved destination for decades. This family-run establishment serves up homemade ice cream using only fresh, local ingredients. The menu features a wide variety of flavors, including fruit-forward options like strawberry cheesecake and mango sorbet, as well as classic comfort treats like chocolate chip cookie dough and birthday cake.

Sweet Charlie’s

With its bright pink facade and cheerful atmosphere, Sweet Charlie’s is a charming ice cream parlor that serves up generous portions of sweet treats. The menu features a blend of traditional and unique flavors, ranging from strawberry cheesecake to pineapple upside-down cake. Don’t forget to try their signature “Charlie Cone,” a waffle cone topped with soft serve, candies, and chocolate sauce.

8. Love Boat Ice Cream

Step into a maritime haven at Love Boat Ice Cream, a whimsical spot that combines the allure of the open sea with the indulgence of ice cream. Boasting a jaw-dropping menu of over 200 flavors, Love Boat offers an unparalleled variety of options, including island-inspired creations like banana Nutella and toasted coconut, as well as classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla. With its salty-sweet atmosphere and endless flavor adventures, Love Boat is a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast.

Flavor	Description
Banana Nutella	A luscious blend of ripe banana and rich Nutella.
Toasted Coconut	Golden flakes of toasted coconut infused into a creamy base.
Pineapple Upside-Down Cake	A delightful combination of sweet pineapple, caramelized brown sugar, and moist cake batter.

Sweet Tooth Satisfaction: Exploring Fort Myers’ Ice Cream Trail

1. Gigi’s Gelato Co.

Experience the sweet indulgence of authentic Italian gelato at Gigi’s Gelato Co. Their handcrafted flavors, made daily with fresh ingredients, will tantalize your taste buds.

2. Sundaes Best

Indulge in the nostalgia of a classic ice cream parlor at Sundaes Best. Choose from their wide selection of handcrafted flavors, piled high on a cone or served in a generous bowl.

3. Island Way Grill

Quench your thirst for something unique at Island Way Grill. Their signature dessert, the “Hurricane Sundae,” will whisk you away with its tropical flavors and decadent toppings.

4. Craft Creamery

Discover the innovative creations of Craft Creamery. Their small-batch ice cream experiments with unexpected flavor combinations, ensuring a one-of-a-kind taste experience.

5. No Sweat Ice Cream

Cool down with a scoop of guilt-free ice cream from No Sweat Ice Cream. Their dairy-free and vegan-friendly offerings cater to all taste buds and dietary restrictions.

6. The Ice Cream Shop

Step back in time at The Ice Cream Shop. Their vintage atmosphere and creamy treats will transport you to a simpler era of ice cream enjoyment.

7. The Ice Cream Smith

Indulge in the artistry of The Ice Cream Smith. Their hand-crafted ice cream pops, topped with decadent glazes and sprinkles, are a feast for the eyes and taste buds.

8. Da Frozen Bean

Escape the heat with a frozen treat from Da Frozen Bean. Their shaved ice and snow cones, topped with an array of colorful syrups and toppings, offer a refreshing burst of flavor.

9. Sweet Life Bake Shop

Satisfy your sweet tooth with a wide selection of delectable ice cream flavors at Sweet Life Bake Shop. From classic favorites to inventive creations, there’s something to please every palate.

Flavor	Description
Kickin’ Key Lime Pie	A tangy blend of key lime juice, graham crackers, and whipped cream
Salty Caramel Pecan	Rich caramel ice cream infused with toasted pecans and a hint of salt
Strawberry Shortcake Bliss	Layers of strawberry ice cream, vanilla cake, and fresh strawberries

10. Cool Creations: Where to Find the Most Unique and Creative Ice Cream Flavors in Fort Myers

Fort Myers is a haven for ice cream lovers who crave unique and creative flavors. Here are some of the best spots to explore:

The Hyppo: Located in the bustling River District, The Hyppo is renowned for its experimental flavors. Think Ploughman’s Lunch (blue cheese, bacon, and walnuts) or Choco Habanero (chocolate, habanero peppers, and a touch of cinnamon).
Peace, Love & Ice Cream: This whimsical ice cream shop on Fort Myers Beach is known for its playful concoctions. Try the Florida Sunset (coconut, mango, and guava) or the Peace Bomb (a vegan treat with cocoa, coffee, and walnuts).
Creamistry: Using liquid nitrogen, Creamistry creates smooth and creamy ice cream on the spot. They offer a rotating menu of classic and innovative flavors, including Thai Iced Tea, Lychee Rose, and Pumpkin Cheesecake.

Name	Address	Unique Flavors
The Hyppo	2205 First Street	Ploughman’s Lunch, Choco Habanero
Peace, Love & Ice Cream	7145 Estero Blvd.	Florida Sunset, Peace Bomb
Creamistry	13901 McGregor Blvd.	Thai Iced Tea, Lychee Rose, Pumpkin Cheesecake

The Sweetest Delights: Finding the Best Ice Cream in Fort Myers, FL

Nestled along the picturesque Gulf Coast, Fort Myers, Florida is a haven for ice cream enthusiasts. With an array of charming ice cream parlors and local gems, the city boasts a rich culinary scene that caters to every craving. Embarking on a culinary journey to discover the best ice cream in Fort Myers is an experience that will leave you savoring every sweet bite.

The Ice Creamery of Lehigh Acres

For those seeking a classic ice cream experience, look no further than The Ice Creamery of Lehigh Acres. This family-owned and operated parlor has been a beloved destination for over 20 years. Their menu features a plethora of traditional flavors, from creamy vanilla to decadent chocolate, as well as a rotating selection of unique creations that will tantalize your taste buds. Indulge in their signature “Superman” ice cream, a colorful blend of blue raspberry, cherry, and lemon, or try their seasonal mango sorbet for a refreshing treat.

Cone Zone

If you’re in search of a modern twist on ice cream, Cone Zone is the place to go. This trendy spot specializes in rolled ice cream, a technique where liquid ice cream is spread thin on a cold plate and rolled into delightful cylinders. Choose from a variety of bases, including coconut milk and gluten-free options, and customize your creation with an array of toppings and add-ins. Whether you prefer classic flavors or innovative combinations like blueberry cheesecake or banana Nutella, Cone Zone has something for every palate.

The Local Scoop

Situated in the heart of downtown Fort Myers, The Local Scoop takes pride in serving locally sourced ice cream. Their small-batch creations are made with fresh milk, cream, and eggs from nearby farms, ensuring a rich and flavorful experience. Their menu changes seasonally, showcasing the bounty of fresh fruit from the region. Savor the sweet taste of strawberry ice cream in the summer or indulge in a pumpkin pie flavor that will warm your taste buds in the fall.